Alabama Mother Pleads Guilty to Murdering Man Alleged of Raping Her, Receives 20-Year Suspended Sentence

Thanks for visiting Popular Crime. The story below is a summary we’re sharing from another news source, who did original reporting on the case. 

Alabama woman pleads guilty to murdering man accused of raping her

Alabama woman pleads guilty to murdering man accused of raping her

An Alabama woman who claimed she acted in self-defense when she shot her alleged rapist has pleaded guilty to his murder.

Brittany Smith on Friday was handed a 20-year sentence, which has been split so that she will serve 18 months in jail, 18 months under house arrest, and then 18.5 years under probation. Because she will receive credit for the time she spent behind bars, Brittany will be released to house arrest in about seven months, her attorney told

Brittany, who is a mother of four, claimed she feared for her life the moment she shot Todd Smith, who is an acquaintance but not related to her.

Her murder charge stems from a deadly confrontation that occurred inside her home in Stevenson on Jan. 16, 2018. Smith told authorities Todd was choking her brother, Chris McCallie, and threatening to kill them when she pulled the trigger.

McCallie showed up at the residence to confront Todd, who was accused of strangling and raping his sister earlier in the night, according to the Alabama news outlet.

The 32-year-old mother previously argued she should not be prosecuted due to the state’s Stand Your Ground Law, but a judge denied her request for immunity, saying she had not proven that the killing was legally justified.

Mom-of-four jailed for murdering man who raped and strangled her and then attacked her brother

THE mom-of-four who shot and killed the man she claimed raped and strangled her before attacking her brother has been jailed.

Brittany Smith, 32, pleaded guilty on Friday and was sentenced to 20 years behind bars, with all but 18 months suspended.

Due to the time she has already served, Smith will serve seven more months in Jackson County Jail, Alabama.

She admitted to shooting dead Todd Smith, 38, no relation, on January 16, 2018, but claimed a Stand Your Ground defense, saying Todd had raped her the previous day.

Her brother Chris MacCallie, had gone to her home in Stevenson, Alabama, to confront Todd about the rape.

Brittany fired three times at Todd after he had her brother in a choke hold and he was turning blue.

Brittany had faced a life in prison if she had been convicted.

Brittany’s attorney, Ron Smith, also no relation, told “We have no control over a jury or a judge that would sentence her.

“In any case, you’ve got to weigh what you know and can control with what you can’t.”

Ramona McCallie, Brittany’s mother, told the site: “My baby girl doesn’t deserve this.”

Alabama’s law allows citizens to use lethal force against someone they believe threatens their safety while committing a burglary.

Lawyers had argued that applied to Todd because he refused to leave Brittany’s home.

But Judge Jenifer Holt ruled she was standing between Todd and the door when she fired, giving him no way out.

And she said the defendant was not entitled to the defense because it was Chris who brought the gun and “initiated” the confrontation.

Judge Holt wrote in February: “The court finds that the defendant has given inconsistent accounts of the events surrounding Todd’s death, beginning with the 911 call… and has attempted to alter or destroy evidence.

“The court further finds that the defendant’s testimony about material facts was significantly at odds with the physical evidence, exhibits and other witness testimony.”

However, a sex assault nurse found more than 30 wounds – including bruises, bite marks and signs of strangulation – on Brittany’s body after the fatal shooting.

The nurse though couldn’t determine with certainty if Brittany had been raped, but noted that most sexual assault cases lack physical proof.

Within 48 hours she was charged with murder and spent four months in jail and another six in a psychiatric institution.

Prosecutors in the case argued that Brittany’s brother was the one who initiated the altercation and he was also the aggressor because he brought a weapon to the house and started the confrontation.

They argued because he had brought the gun, Brittany wasn’t entitled to the Stand Your Ground defense.

Brittany claimed Todd had choked her to the point of unconsciousness and raped her at her home in Stevenson, Alabama, on January 15, 2018 and threatened to kill her if she told anyone.

It was revealed in February this year that Todd had a long list of offenses against his name and had been arrested 71 times.

Todd’s ex-wife, 37-year-old Paige Parker, allegedly described him as an “evil monster” when she was approached by the Daily Mail.

Paige was “beaten, raped, and sodomized” and reportedly her nose broken by Todd within the first few weeks of their marriage.

Their marriage lasted from July 2002 until June 2003.

Arrest records showed he had a history of DUIs, drug charges, shoplifting, vandalism, trespass and assaults.

Alabama woman pleads guilty to murdering man accused of raping her
Brittany was sentenced to 20 years, all but 18 months were suspended Credit: Stevenson Police Department

Thanks to Hunt A Killer for this great deal

We’ve partnered with a terrific new immersive game experience for True Crime fans like us.

And for a limited time, they have let us know that readers or PopularCrime can take 20% off their first box by using the code POPULARCRIME at checkout. We hope you enjoy the game as much as we do and join us as we unravel the clues in the latest box every month.

Choose Your Plan  

Popular Crime pulls in news of current and historical true crime cases from all over the world. The above excerpted is reprinted here under the provisions of Fair Use. Any and all reporting was done by the original publisher. We encourage you to visit the original publisher.

For more information about our site, click here.


Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on pinterest
Share on reddit
Share on email

Leave a Reply